We're glad you are here. This is the place to ask for bag advice, help other people out, post reviews, and share photos and videos.

TOM BIHN Forums Statistics


Topics: 15,030   Posts: 194,194   Members: 6,926   Active Members: 194
Welcome to our newest member, PCW57.


No announcement yet.

Empire Builder & Zephyr: A Comparison, Part II

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Empire Builder & Zephyr: A Comparison, Part II

    Now, on to the main zipper compartment. This is where the Empire Builder carries its extra space over the Zephyr. Neither bag is skimpy on storage capacity. But the Empire Builder's main pocket is really, really big.

    Here is the inside of the Zephyr:

    Click image for larger version

Name:	Zephyr Measure.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	56.5 KB
ID:	308275

    And the inside of the Empire Builder:

    Click image for larger version

Name:	Empire Measure.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	60.5 KB
ID:	308276

    The Empire Builder's main compartment is also wider than the Zephyr's. (The plastic file dividers inside the Empire are 16 1/2" wide, about an inch wider than those inside the Zephyr.)

    To give a more practical idea of the size of this compartment, the Zephyr can hold this many books, front to back:

    Click image for larger version

Name:	Zephyr Books.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	67.1 KB
ID:	308277

    The Empire can hold two more:

    Click image for larger version

Name:	Empire Books.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	68.6 KB
ID:	308278

    Either bag can easily accommodate two rows of novel-sized books side by side. So that means the Empire Builder can handle about four more books of this size than the Zephyr can. When thinking about space, incidentally, keep in mind that both bags are taller than a lot of other briefcases out there. Which means that even when the bag is full front to back (with books, for example), there's still plenty of room for things on top of them.

    Of course, some of this compartment may be taken up with a laptop and a Brain Cell, so YMMV depending on how much space your computer/Brain Cell combo requires. For example, a 13-inch Macbook takes a size 6 Brain Cell, which is just shy of 2" deep front to back. So with the Brain Cell installed, that leaves about 2" of main compartment for books, files and other stuff in the Zephyr, or 4" in the Empire Builder. (If your laptop needs a Brain Cell larger than a size 4X, it won't fit inside the Zephyr, so the Empire Builder wins by default.)

    I didn't include photos of the back of the bags either, because there isn't that much difference between them to see. Except for one thing: I found the big open back pouch on the Empire Builder to be a little too open. I liked the extra space--you could easily slide the Sunday New York Times in there. But the pocket is so big that if there are only a couple of things in there--say a book and a sunglass case--the opening tends to bow out from the bag and rub against my leg while I'm walking. It's a pretty minor thing, but noticeable enough that I wanted some way to fasten the opening to keep things from falling out. That same pouch on the Zephyr is smaller, and lays more tightly against the back wall of the bag--but still holds plenty. Maybe not the Sunday NYT, but certainly Thursday's.

    So which bag is for you? Beats me. It all depends on how much you carry and how much bag you want/need to have with you on the go. There is no doubt that the Empire Builder feels larger than the Zephyr, which is noticeably more compact. But the difference isn't so dramatic that one feels like a purse and the other a footlocker. If you are really tall, or if you're used to carrying around a large briefcase, or if you need to haul around A LOT of stuff, the Zephyr might not be enough bag for you. If you are not really tall, or you don't have that much stuff, the Empire Builder might feel like too much bag.

    For what it's worth, I'm six feet tall, and for what I usually take with me in my daily rounds--a Macbook, iPod, phone, wireless card, thumb drive, assorted chargers/cables, wallet, sunglasses, keys, digicam, couple of books, spiral notebook, magazines, loose papers, pens, pocket knife, small flashlight, granola bar and an apple--the Empire Builder seemed like overkill. The Empire could hold two of everything I just listed and still have room left over. (In fact, a fairly loaded up Zephyr easily fits INSIDE the Empire Builder, with space left over in the main compartment for four 250-page paperbacks.)

    Obviously, the Zephyr isn't that cavernous. But it does hold everything on my list and still has room for, say, two more novel-sized books, three magazines, six CDs in jewel cases, a small digital video camera and a light windbreaker. With all that inside the bag is full to the top (that's where the bag's extra height comes in handy), but it isn't bulging and still zippers easily.

    For me, the Zephyr is the perfect size. That said, if I had a 17-inch laptop, or if I had needed a roomier travel bag for airline carry-on, I would have picked the Empire Builder.

    In other words, don't sweat it. There are no bad choices here.
    Last edited by Zasky; 09-16-2007, 05:37 PM.

    Thanks so much for posting your data, Zasky. This has done much to clarify the relative difference between the two bags. Much appreciated!:)
    Bags: Latest: Pop Tote and Shop Bag (large) ; also have a Co-Pilot, Super Ego (w/cork seatbelt); Aeronaut; Medium Cafe Bag; Large Cafe Bag; Brain Cell; Shop Bag small, (Steel); Packing Cube Shoulder Bag. Accessories: Oh yeah, bunches.
    Sadly Lost to Hazmat: An Imago in Steel/Cork & MCB in Linen/Olive.
    " ...all [that] you have to depend on is yourself and your luggage." - The Luggage Salesman (Joe Versus the Volcano)


      Thank you for your great pictures they really "show" the difference between the two bags.