We're glad you are here. This is the place to ask for bag advice, help other people out, post reviews, and share photos and videos.

TOM BIHN Forums Statistics


Topics: 14,995   Posts: 193,731   Members: 6,892   Active Members: 243
Welcome to our newest member, B-Con.


No announcement yet.

Problem Picking a Id or a Brian Bag.

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Problem Picking a Id or a Brian Bag.


    I am debating about purchasing an Id or a Brain Bag. I like the messenger for all the pockets and the messenger sort of thing going on. But I like the Brain bag for the amount of space. The Brian Bag with a vertical slip is what I am looking at.

    I now have a messenger type of bag. I like holding it on one shoulder. I would be open to a brain bag if it is a comfortable haul on one shoulder. I probably wouldn't use it with both straps. Is the Brain Bag comfortable holding it over one shoulder? Any other comments?

    Many thanks...
    Last edited by BrianW; 05-07-2008, 12:09 PM. Reason: spelling problems

    Brain Bag, really for 2-shoulder use

    Hi there!

    I think the Brain Bag is not a good choice for (more than occasional, fleeting, emergency) one-shoulder use. It is *excellent* for two-shoulder use, but if you anticipate / prefer use as a sling-bag, I think the Id would suit you better.

    Why? Because the Brain bag, when well loaded, becomes a pretty rectilinear package (much more than it looks when unloaded or barely loaded). And that's great, from a stuff-per-ounce-of-enclosure viewpoint, but it means that there's a definite best side to contact your back, and that's the nicely padded panel you're against when carrying it conventionally.

    However, if you want the capacity of the Brain Bag, what about the SuperEgo? It's not 36 Liters, but it's large (27 liters), esp. compared to the Id (20.9 liters). However, it's also *large* in the "gee, that is a large bag" sense, so perhaps the Id is a better match for your body (no idea!). I think I like the *look* of the Id better (pretty neutral between them, actually), but just ordered a Super Ego for the size.

    Last edited by timothy; 05-07-2008, 09:46 PM.