Welcome!

We're glad you are here. This is the place to ask for bag advice, help other people out, post reviews, and share photos and videos.

TOM BIHN Forums Statistics

Collapse

Topics: 14,580   Posts: 188,317   Members: 6,539   Active Members: 284
Welcome to our newest member, RosellaFvg.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Think the Sidekick will work?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Think the Sidekick will work?

    I will be doing a lot of international travel over the next few years and am looking for a bag I can use inflight, carbinered to the seatback pocket, that will fit in the bottom of my S25. I’m thinking a SK may work but am certainly open to other ideas. I will carry a Kindle paperwhite, Anker 20000 mAh battery, iPhone X, charging blocks/cables for the mentioned electronics, and a pair of Bose QC35s without the case, I’ll also have other little things that I should be able to squirrel away. The only concern I have with the SK is that the headphones will take up too much room. Thoughts? I appreciate it.

    #2
    Welcome to the Forums sgtd

    I like all the blues and greys...and all the happy citrus colours too! My search unicorn is the Sapphire Dyneema original Small Shop Bag...

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by sgtd View Post
      I will be doing a lot of international travel over the next few years and am looking for a bag I can use inflight, carbinered to the seatback pocket, that will fit in the bottom of my S25. I’m thinking a SK may work but am certainly open to other ideas. I will carry a Kindle paperwhite, Anker 20000 mAh battery, iPhone X, charging blocks/cables for the mentioned electronics, and a pair of Bose QC35s without the case, I’ll also have other little things that I should be able to squirrel away. The only concern I have with the SK is that the headphones will take up too much room. Thoughts? I appreciate it.
      If you want something to clip to the seat pocket the Sidekick would be your best bet. It's my favorite TB bag. The headphones will take up quite a bit of space. You would save a bit of room without the case. I have some photos of my QC35's in the case in a SK here.

      I do really like the ability to slip my SK into my S25 on trips. If you wanted to go a step up in size and didn't need to clip it to the seat you could go with a Co-Pilot. I like traveling with mine because of the water bottle pocket which comes in handy for travelling. I usually keep my essentials inside of a Side Effect or a HLT inside of the Co-Pilot. I'll take some photos of my SK with my iPhone, battery, and headphones tomorrow.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by G42 View Post
        Welcome to the Forums sgtd

        Thank you very much. It’s good to be here.


        Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by Awesomepants View Post
          If you want something to clip to the seat pocket the Sidekick would be your best bet. It's my favorite TB bag. The headphones will take up quite a bit of space. You would save a bit of room without the case. I have some photos of my QC35's in the case in a SK here.

          I do really like the ability to slip my SK into my S25 on trips. If you wanted to go a step up in size and didn't need to clip it to the seat you could go with a Co-Pilot. I like traveling with mine because of the water bottle pocket which comes in handy for travelling. I usually keep my essentials inside of a Side Effect or a HLT inside of the Co-Pilot. I'll take some photos of my SK with my iPhone, battery, and headphones tomorrow.
          I appreciate the picture. I was thinking I’d go without the case to save room, understanding I’m giving up some protection for being able to fit more stuff.

          As far as the copilot goes I’ll take a look at it. I was thinking the SK because it allows me to carry just the S25 but the copilot may work a little better.

          I appreciate your help.


          Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

          Comment


            #6
            The SK (even in Halcyon) probably doesn’t offer the expandability and front to back depth those headphones would require.

            Here are some other bags to consider.

            An HLT2 might work if you take advantage of the front outside pocket to store some items to offset the amount of space the headphones will consume. The HLT2 is deeper than the SK and the clamshell zipper makes it easier to fit larger items inside - smaller items can be packed around larger ones before zipping the bag shut.

            Otherwise my best recommendation would be a Packing Cube Shoulder Bag. However, it lacks any organization, save one front zippered pocket, and the snaphook attachment points (now sewn to the front/back sides opposed to the left/right) might not make it the best bag for the back of a plane seat. It also is not stocked or in production. You’d likely have to search for one on a site like eBay.

            What about a large Snake Charmer, clipped to the seat back by one double sided carabiner? It’s a non traditional solution, but based on in-stock inventory and the items you need to carry, it might be feasible. The mesh sides would make it easier to find items, too.

            If nothing else, and you can afford it, order more than you need, test pack the bags at home (without removing the hang tags), keep which bag works best and send back the rest for a refund.

            Hope that helps!


            Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
            Follow me on Instagram!

            @outside_chicago

            @wright_in_the_midwest

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by Chicagoan View Post
              The SK (even in Halcyon) probably doesn’t offer the expandability and front to back depth those headphones would require.

              Here are some other bags to consider.

              An HLT2 might work if you take advantage of the front outside pocket to store some items to offset the amount of space the headphones will consume. The HLT2 is deeper than the SK and the clamshell zipper makes it easier to fit larger items inside - smaller items can be packed around larger ones before zipping the bag shut.

              Otherwise my best recommendation would be a Packing Cube Shoulder Bag. However, it lacks any organization, save one front zippered pocket, and the snaphook attachment points (now sewn to the front/back sides opposed to the left/right) might not make it the best bag for the back of a plane seat. It also is not stocked or in production. You’d likely have to search for one on a site like eBay.

              What about a large Snake Charmer, clipped to the seat back by one double sided carabiner? It’s a non traditional solution, but based on in-stock inventory and the items you need to carry, it might be feasible. The mesh sides would make it easier to find items, too.

              If nothing else, and you can afford it, order more than you need, test pack the bags at home (without removing the hang tags), keep which bag works best and send back the rest for a refund.

              Hope that helps!


              Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
              I appreciate the feedback. The depth of the SK is what worries me. I did look at the Snake Charmer and it's intriguing. I would like something with some internal organization but I could always use pouches. I also looked at the HLT 2 and think it may work. I'm also looking at the Copilot but that may be just a little too big. Thanks again for the comments.

              Comment


                #8
                Hi sgtd,

                I’m going to point you to one more thread with pictures and discussion.
                Bose QC-25/35 and co-pilot
                This shows a solution with the Packing Cube Shoulder Bag, which can fit into the S25 chin pocket (or, I the case of the post shown, suspended in front of a Pilot). It can also be suspended through Carabiners to act as a seat pocket bag. You can drop a Side Kick inside of one. The big issue is that the redesign of the PCSB to put the Strap attachment points at offset positions at the front and back instead of at the sides of the bag make this more awkward (but not impossible) to suspend with Carabiners. Earlier versions of the Side Kick were also easier to suspend, but the adjustment is easier to hack than for the PCSBs. (The designs for both bags were changed in June 2018, to prevent possible zipper wear and tear). See Please bring back the snaphook on the SK. See my post for pictures of the Side Kick before and after. Darcy’s post in the earlier thread shows a way to suspend with the current Side Kick.

                Again, if you can manage with the Side Kick, it would be best, and you may gain a bit by taking the headphones out of the case, and possibly a little more flexibility with Halcyon, but it might be tight.

                My guess is that the Side Kick would work better than the HLT 2. The first linked thread shows another solution with the Daylight Briefcase, but the PCSB would be smaller (pictures there show the relative size of PCSB, which is wider than the DLBC).

                HTH

                moriond
                Last edited by moriond; 08-24-2020, 01:51 PM.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by moriond View Post
                  Hi sgtd,

                  I’m going to point you to one more thread with pictures and discussion.
                  Bose QC-25/35 and co-pilot
                  This shows a solution with the Packing Cube Shoulder Bag, which can fit into the S25 chin pocket (or, I the case of the post shown, suspended in front of a Pilot). It can also be suspended through Carabiners to act as a seat pocket bag. You can drop a Side Kick inside of one. The big issue is that the redesign of the PCSB to put the Strap attachment points at offset positions at the front and back instead of at the sides of the bag make this more awkward (but not impossible) to suspend with Carabiners. Earlier versions of the Side Kick were also easier to suspend, but the adjustment is easier to hack than for the PCSBs. (The designs for both bags were changed in June 2018, to prevent possible zipper wear and tear). See Please bring back the snaphook on the SK. See my post for pictures of the Side Kick before and after. Darcy’s post in the earlier thread shows a way to suspend with the current Side Kick.

                  Again, if you can manage with the Side Kick, it would be best, and you may gain a bit by taking the headphones out of the case, and possibly a little more flexibility with Halcyon, but it might be tight.

                  My guess is that the Side Kick would work better than the HLT 2. The first linked thread shows another solution with the Daylight Briefcase, but the PCSB would be smaller (pictures there show the relative size of PCSB, which is wider than the DLBC).

                  HTH

                  moriond
                  This absolutely helps; thank you very much for the comments!

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Think the Sidekick will work?

                    Originally posted by sgtd View Post
                    This absolutely helps; thank you very much for the comments!
                    Now I’m curious. Anyone out there with both an SK and HLT2 who also owns a similar pair of headphones and can compare how headphones fit inside?

                    My guess is the the SK is going to prove too shallow, even with the slight flexibility added by Halcyon.

                    The SK was my go-to/EDC for a long time and it doesn’t respond well to a singular large item when the only access into the main compartment is a zipper along the top edge. The headphones are really going to arbitrate the bag. If you need a bag to fit those, start there. If you can use something else instead, you’ll be more open to using other bag options. But if they truly are the number one priority, be sure you pick the best bag for those.

                    My money is on the clamshell style opening of the HLT2, as well as how much the middle of the bag can expand outward. It carries more like a cylinder than a cube, while the SK is very committed to maintaining its box-like shape.

                    Due respect to your advice and suspicions, moriond, and if nothing else, it makes a strong case to at least audition the SK and HLT2!


                    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                    Last edited by Chicagoan; 08-24-2020, 02:28 PM.
                    Follow me on Instagram!

                    @outside_chicago

                    @wright_in_the_midwest

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by sgtd View Post
                      I appreciate the picture. I was thinking I’d go without the case to save room, understanding I’m giving up some protection for being able to fit more stuff.

                      As far as the copilot goes I’ll take a look at it. I was thinking the SK because it allows me to carry just the S25 but the copilot may work a little better.

                      I appreciate your help.


                      Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                      Depending on how much extra stuff you want to pack with the headphones it's doable in a SK. Even though the halcyon version allows it to be more stuffed, I'd recommend the ballistic if you want to hang it form a seat back since it the bag will be more rigid. The bag was pretty stuffed with all the things I put in the photos but had a room for a tiny bit more.

                      I took some photos packing a RavPower 22,000 mAh battery, sunglasses, a 200ml tiger bottle, iphone cable (I was using the iPhone to take the photo so I didn't put it in the picture), a few pens, a super mini Ghost Whale, a small flashlight, a Kindle Paperwhite, and an Acuity fabric 3DOC.

                      I also added some photos of the headphones in a size 2 Sitka travel stuff sack and a size 2 HLT in Solaris. The HLT had room for more things than I put in there, but would hold less than I packed in the SK.

                      Click image for larger version

Name:	1-w800.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	132.2 KB
ID:	307678
                      Click image for larger version

Name:	2-w800.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	94.3 KB
ID:	307679
                      Click image for larger version

Name:	3-w800.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	148.9 KB
ID:	307680
                      Click image for larger version

Name:	4-w800.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	121.2 KB
ID:	307681
                      Click image for larger version

Name:	5-w800.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	142.0 KB
ID:	307682
                      Click image for larger version

Name:	6-w800.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	149.1 KB
ID:	307683
                      Click image for larger version

Name:	7-w800.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	160.6 KB
ID:	307684
                      Click image for larger version

Name:	8-w800.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	264.5 KB
ID:	307685
                      Click image for larger version

Name:	9-w800.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	164.9 KB
ID:	307686

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by Awesomepants View Post
                        Depending on how much extra stuff you want to pack with the headphones it's doable in a SK. Even though the halcyon version allows it to be more stuffed, I'd recommend the ballistic if you want to hang it form a seat back since it the bag will be more rigid. The bag was pretty stuffed with all the things I put in the photos but had a room for a tiny bit more.

                        I took some photos packing a RavPower 22,000 mAh battery, sunglasses, a 200ml tiger bottle, iphone cable (I was using the iPhone to take the photo so I didn't put it in the picture), a few pens, a super mini Ghost Whale, a small flashlight, a Kindle Paperwhite, and an Acuity fabric 3DOC.

                        I also added some photos of the headphones in a size 2 Sitka travel stuff sack and a size 2 HLT in Solaris. The HLT had room for more things than I put in there, but would hold less than I packed in the SK.

                        [ATTACH=CONFIG]24998[/ATTACH]
                        [ATTACH=CONFIG]24999[/ATTACH]
                        [ATTACH=CONFIG]25000[/ATTACH]
                        [ATTACH=CONFIG]25001[/ATTACH]
                        [ATTACH=CONFIG]25002[/ATTACH]
                        [ATTACH=CONFIG]25003[/ATTACH]
                        [ATTACH=CONFIG]25004[/ATTACH]
                        [ATTACH=CONFIG]25005[/ATTACH]
                        [ATTACH=CONFIG]25006[/ATTACH]
                        This was super helpful. I really appreciate all the pictures and explanation of how things fit. Based on this I think I may try a SK. Now to decide the colors...


                        Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Chicagoan,

                          The HLT 2 might work better, depending on the shape of the headphones and what else he is carrying. I have a Halcyon Side Kick, and I don’t have the QC35s. The Side Kick is taller and longer, and I also get a lot more flexibility with Halcyon, so the advantage I saw when I grabbed another set of (Beats) headphones and tried it in both was that the remaining space in the Side Kick after putting the Kindle inside was more useable for fitting in battery packs, etc. Remember he has to secure the remaining items inside the HLT 2.

                          I used to carry earlier (larger) Bose headphones, but now I use ear buds. My phone (iPhone SE) is also a lot smaller than most people carry, so I can’t do an accurate simulation of his carry.

                          HTH

                          moriond

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Think the Sidekick will work?

                            moriond

                            I’ve found the best way to get the most out of a bag is by packing it with smaller items. As soon as you put one large item inside, you start diminishing the flexibility of the fabric. Now, “large” as it stands in relation to to the overall size of the bag. For example, an iPad Mini (about the same height and width dimensions as a Side Kick) will fit in the main compartment’s back pocket, but when you make one full side of the bag rigid, you can only pack the bag out further in one direction instead of two. So, while the Mini can fit inside the bag, it’s better suited for a large bag where it won’t compromise the overall volume.

                            Awesomepants

                            Your reply lives up to your username and how helpful you were to respond with not only the two bags in question, but most of the items the OP was concerned about fitting inside the bags.

                            sgtd

                            The first bag I ever bought from Tom Bihn was a Side Kick. I only needed it as a park bag for a vacation to Disney World. I wound up wearing it every day, even after I’d come home from the trip. Since it loads from the top, you can walk around with it unzipped for easy access, but it’s able to be completely zipped up for the sake of security or weatherproofing, too. I think you’ll be surprised with how much it can hold. Even once you think it’s “full,” there’s usually space near the top to tuck a pair of sunglasses (which I see Awesomepants taking advantage of, too). It’s a really great bag and I think you’ll be really pleased with how much difference a little organization can make in part of your life.


                            Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                            Last edited by Chicagoan; 08-24-2020, 05:49 PM.
                            Follow me on Instagram!

                            @outside_chicago

                            @wright_in_the_midwest

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Between the Sidekick and the Pilot is the Daylight Briefcase.

                              It is slightly bigger than the Sidekick and much smaller than the Pilot.

                              You might also want to consider the Copilot.

                              https://www.tombihn.com/collections/...=2048083853319

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X