Welcome!

We're glad you are here. This is the place to ask for bag advice, help other people out, post reviews, and share photos and videos.

TOM BIHN Forums Statistics

Collapse

Topics: 14,521   Posts: 187,739   Members: 6,485   Active Members: 309
Welcome to our newest member, questah043.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Copilot VS cadet

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Copilot VS cadet

    OK TB aficionados, I am looking for advice...again.

    This time I am Christmas shopping (yes, in June) for a friend who loves luggage/bags but has not experienced Tom Bihn. I am debating between a copilot and a cadet. This individual is retired, travels frequently but does not seem to fly which is a good thing because they are a multi-multi-bag traveler. Yes, they have computer(s) with their own bags already. I am considering the copilot or cadet as an EDC to carry all those little widgets that need a home while travelling and to introduce TB.

    Anyone have an opinion on which may be a better bag? A different bag I should consider?

    Thanks in advance.

    #2
    What kind of computer? What kind of travel? What sorts of widgets?

    I ask because to my mind, the C-P and Cadet are fairly dissimilar, and it depends what kind of travel your friend is doing. The Cadet is also very much a laptop bag (and it looks like one), if that makes a difference.

    You're a pretty great friend, I must say. Do you need any more friends?

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by Badger View Post
      You're a pretty great friend, I must say. Do you need any more friends?
      Well, Badger; are you a Bucky Badger, If so we are already generally friends. The particular friend I am shopping for has *earned* a TB from me. I will say more in 2013 :-)

      To answer your questions, assume car / bus travel. Computers are multiple and each have their own computer bag.

      Widgets: name it, dream it, they have it. Very tough to shop for, but I am thinking an array of organizer pouches will provide flexibility.

      (Katy, if you are monitoring, get ready ;-) )
      Last edited by lonestar6; 06-25-2012, 10:42 AM.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by lonestar6 View Post
        I will say more in 2013 :-)
        Whoa, that's cryptic. And yeah, I was at UW for 8 (lengthy) years. Technically, I'm still there, in fact. Ahem. Anyway, long enough to own a Sconnie T-shirt and feel scorn towards Iowa, which is unfortunate.

        Since the compys all have their own bags, I'd go Co-Pilot. It's such a great little bag. Your friend will love it. If you think s/he might need a little more room, an Imago might be worth a look, too.

        Comment


          #5
          Class of '95, Dairy Sci PhD. I landed in Indiana which is less contentious.

          Comment


            #6
            Dairy science, nice. My father was in Poultry Science at Oregon State. The dairy people were where it's at.

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by Badger View Post
              Since the compys all have their own bags, I'd go Co-Pilot. It's such a great little bag. Your friend will love it. If you think s/he might need a little more room, an Imago might be worth a look, too.
              Agreed! The Co-Pilot would make a great first Tom Bihn Bag!!!
              http://www.tombihn.com
              1-800-729-9607 (US & Canada) 360-452-0115 (other countries)
              Siquid mantica non capit, domi relinquendum est.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by lonestar6 View Post
                Well, Badger; are you a Bucky Badger, If so we are already generally friends. The particular friend I am shopping for has *earned* a TB from me. I will say more in 2013 :-)

                To answer your questions, assume car / bus travel. Computers are multiple and each have their own computer bag.

                Widgets: name it, dream it, they have it. Very tough to shop for, but I am thinking an array of organizer pouches will provide flexibility.

                (Katy, if you are monitoring, get ready ;-) )
                I can be reached at 1 (800) 729-9607
                Please ignore my scratchy voice.
                http://www.tombihn.com
                1-800-729-9607 (US & Canada) 360-452-0115 (other countries)
                Siquid mantica non capit, domi relinquendum est.

                Comment


                  #9
                  I also would weigh in on the Co-Pilot side...it is a bit more flexible for widget segmentation, but makes a nice place to stuff an iPad and such.

                  ...and it is just so darn CUTE! The struggle then is Dyneema or Cordura...hmm.
                  ============================================

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by jeffmac View Post
                    ...and it is just so darn CUTE! The struggle then is Dyneema or Cordura...hmm.
                    That was going to be my follow on question. I like the Dyneema and I imagine it lightens the pack an ounce or two, but how durable is it as a shell and does the bag maintain its shape well with the dyneema?

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by lonestar6 View Post
                      That was going to be my follow on question. I like the Dyneema and I imagine it lightens the pack an ounce or two, but how durable is it as a shell and does the bag maintain its shape well with the dyneema?
                      I have a Dyneema Synapse, and I have no doubts about its strength and durability. I do think that it is not as stiff as Ballistic Cordura, but (at least with the Synapse) it doesn't flop all over the place, either. And according to the C-P page, the Dyneema version is six ounces lighter. Not insignificant. However, I'd go with the color combination your friend would like the most, the thing that is most him/her.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Grey for sure. But dyneema comes in grey still. Although the white stripes may be too wild for the individual in mind. I on the other hand ...

                        Comment


                          #13
                          If they're more formal and tend to carry files with them on their travels, a Cadet might be nice. If they're more casual, the Co-Pilot might be a better choice. I "borrowed" my Mom's Co-Pilot and used it as my everyday work bag for a few weeks a few month ago to see if I could make do carrying a smaller bag and less stuff. I was surprised with how versatile it was and how much I could actually carry in it. I also liked that I got to the point that I knew what gear was in which pockets. The fact it could early carry a water bottle was a plus, although my larger 24-oz Kleen Kanteen and 24-oz Lifefactory bottles couldn't be fully zipped into the pocket. Since Mom's is the Black/Steel, it wasn't too out of place in my work settings - I'm an architect, so that included the office, client meetings, and job sites (plus we're "expected" to be a bit odd and have unusual gear). I ultimately decided the Co-Pilot wasn't the everyday bag for me - it just wasn't quite large enough - I really need to be able to carry a portfolio and/or binder with letter-size paper.
                          Aeronaut in Black/Iberian, Synapse in Black/Iberian, Small Cafe Bag in Linen/Steel, 4Z Horizontal Cache in Black, iPad Vertical Cache in Black, 3D Organizer Cube in Steel, Large Clear Organizer in Pouch Iberian, Medium Clear Organizer Pouch in Iberian, Mini Padded Organizer Pouch in Black, Mini Organizer Pouch in Iberian, 16" Key Strap in Sapphire, 8" Key Strap in Storm

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by lonestar6 View Post
                            Grey for sure. But dyneema comes in grey still. Although the white stripes may be too wild for the individual in mind. I on the other hand ...
                            If it helps, Steel (in ballistic or denier) is a true grey. Steel Dyneema is much closer to black, IMO.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              I have a steel dyneema backpack packing cube which I absolutely adore. I am looking at the pcsb in Iberian. When I get a smaller computer a Synapse will join the family unless I fall in love with the copilot... oh my, is there s TB 12 step program?

                              Anyway I was wondering about the dyneema to round out my understanding should I be in the market for personal use. So thanks much to everyone for your input!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X